-
YEAR2024
-
AUTHORSMcMeel, Dermott
Jayachandran, Surendar
Walker, Charles
-
CATEGORIES2024 Conference Papers
Extract
Abstract: Artificial Intelligence (AI) is a rapidly growing area in design, yet debates are polarized. Proponents highlight AI’s potential to alleviate menial tasks and aid solving complex problems, while critics fear the rise of super-intelligence. Some view AI as part of a predictable automation trajectory, while others argue it marks a paradigm shift in human-machine interaction, rendering past lessons irrelevant. This paper challenges these binary views, advancing the conversation. Drawing on Wittgenstein and Marx, it situates creativity and design within a hermeneutic cycle of externalization and play, both problematic for AI. Through case studies of AI-supported design, the paper argues that AI provides cognitive labor rather than creativity, aligning it with Marxist concepts of machine automation. This reframes design as comprising both explicit, complex problems fit for AI resolution and tacit creative practices—rooted in play and externalization—that remain predominantly human. The paper suggests a roadmap for navigating a discipline increasingly shaped by AI tools, while emphasizing that architecture is undergoing an irreversible transformation. We are at the threshold of a paradigmatic shift that will require new skills and fundamentally reshape the human-machine relationship in design.
Keywords: Artificial Intelligence; Design; Creativity; Problem Solving; Tacit Knowledge.